AEO Answer · Electrical

How Are Automatic Transfer Switches Specified and Applied?

By Jeremy Mills, CEO & Founder, Apex Grid Engineering — USAF Veteran. · Updated 2026-09-15

ATS design selects the transition type (open, closed, or delayed), ratings, and controls for the loads served, then engineers the emergency distribution and load priorities around it. The switch monitors utility power, starts the generator on failure, and transfers loads — the critical design work is deciding what actually transfers.

I'm Jeremy Mills, CEO & Founder of Apex Grid Engineering and a U.S. Air Force veteran. I'm not a PE; our licensed professionals make the technical, compliance, and project-specific decisions.

Illustrative diagram of building MEP systems: ductwork with diffusers, an electrical panel with conduit, and piping runs.

The concise answer

ATS design selects the transition type (open, closed, or delayed), ratings, and controls for the loads served, then engineers the emergency distribution and load priorities around it. The switch monitors utility power, starts the generator on failure, and transfers loads — the critical design work is deciding what actually transfers. The discipline the ATS imposes is load honesty. Every load on emergency power has to justify itself, because generator capacity is expensive and finite. The transfer switch one-line is where the owner, the code, and the budget negotiate — and the engineer runs the negotiation.

Sizing and selecting the switch

The ATS ampere rating must handle the connected emergency load plus motor inrush — transferring onto a generator means the switch sees starting currents, not running currents. For large motor loads, delayed transition or in-phase monitoring prevents the mechanical shock of re-energizing a spinning motor out of phase. Controls are where modern ATS units earn their keep: programmable time delays, load-shed contacts, communication to the building automation system, and event logging. I specify the control features around the facility's operating plan — a hospital's ATS controls look different from a retail building's, because the operators' needs are different.

Designing the emergency distribution

The transfer switch is one component; the emergency system is the design. Separation, selectivity, and testing access make it work when it counts. My emergency distribution standards:

  • Priority segregation: separate transfer switches for emergency, standby, and optional loads
  • Selective coordination verified: emergency system fully coordinated so one fault can't cascade
  • Generator sized to the priorities: load calculations per priority level, with load shed where it pays
  • Testing designed in: load-bank connections and test switches so monthly testing is easy, not heroic
  • Retransfer engineered: time delays and sequencing that bring loads back to utility without a second outage

What else do project teams ask?

What's the difference between open and closed transition?
Open transition breaks from the utility before connecting the generator — power interrupts briefly, typically under 10 seconds total including generator start. Closed transition momentarily parallels both sources for a seamless transfer, which avoids the interruption but requires utility approval, paralleling-rated switchgear, and more complex controls. Most commercial projects use open transition.
Do I need bypass isolation on a transfer switch?
For critical facilities — hospitals, data centers, 24/7 operations — yes. Bypass isolation lets you service or replace the ATS without de-energizing the emergency loads. It's a significant cost adder, so for standard commercial buildings I evaluate whether the maintenance window risk justifies it. Where downtime isn't an option, it's not optional.
How are loads prioritized across multiple transfer switches?
By code article and function: emergency (life safety) loads transfer first and can't be shed; legally required standby next; optional standby last, often with load-shed controls. I use separate transfer switches per priority level so a fault or overload on optional loads can never take down emergency power. Priority discipline is what keeps generator sizes sane.
What causes nuisance transfers?
Usually voltage sensing set too tight — the ATS sees a utility sag and transfers for what was a two-second event. Proper pickup/dropout voltage and time-delay settings ride through normal utility fluctuations. I also see nuisance transfers from a generator exercised without load, masking a unit that can't actually carry the building. Monthly loaded testing catches both.

Ready to discuss your engineering scope?

Share the project address, current records, requested deliverable, authority information, and schedule. Apex Grid confirms professional responsibility, availability, and scope before work begins.

Request a Project Review

Get a quote on your project

Reviewed and sealed by licensed PEs. “Solid engineering and clear communication from start to finish.” — Jason Mitchell, Principal Architect

Tell us what you need and where the project is — quotes back within 12–24 hours on qualifying scopes.